Author Archives: Jeff Sovern

Paper Examines Overdraft Regulation and Markets in US, UK, and Israel

Harvard SJD candidate Aluma Zernik has written When Markets, Consumers and Regulators Collide: Overdrafts in the US, UK and Israel. Here's the abstract: There is a fierce debate in the US about whether to regulate overdrafts and, specifically, about whether overdraft should be limited or prices should be capped. Proponents of regulation claim overdrafts are not […]

Mulvaney Wants Congress to Block CFPB Payday Lending Rule and is Reviewing Pending Enforcement Cases

by Jeff Sovern So reports the American Banker.  Mulvaney can't simply rescind the payday lending rule without going through the time-consuming notice and comment process. But if the rule takes effect, and the industry challenges it, what happens if Mulvaney orders the CFPB lawyers not to defend the rule? Does the CFPB have an obligation […]

Dodd-Frank Authors, Including Dodd And Frank, on How Congress Didn’t Want the Vacancies Act to Apply to the CFPB

The architects of the Dodd-Frank Act, including former Senator Dodd, former Representative Frank, and former Treasury official Michael Barr, held a press conference on Thursday to make the point that Congress did not want the Vacancies Act to apply to the CFPB.  The American Banker has a report here.  Excerpt: They said a federal judge […]

Kar and Radin Article: Pseudo-Contract & Shared Meaning Analysis

Robin Bradley Kar of Illinois and Margaret Jane Radin of Toronto and Michigan have written Pseudo-Contract & Shared Meaning Analysis. Here is the abstract: Over the last several decades, courts have struggled with when to enforce boilerplate text as contract. An example is the copious digital text that consumers receive links to before clicking “I agree” […]

CFPB Judge Promises to Decide Case Quickly as DOJ Attorney Refuses to Pledge that English Won’t Lose Job

The Wall Street Journal reports here. Excerpt: Asked by the judge if he could provide assurance that the administration wouldn’t take any adverse action against Ms. English that could immediately affect the case, [Brett Shumate, deputy assistant attorney general for federal programs] replied, “Loss of a position is not irreparable harm.”

English v. Mulvaney & Trump: Some Reasons Why It Matters

by Jeff Sovern A couple of people have suggested to me that it doesn't really matter who wins as between English and Mulvaney because Trump will still get to nominate a new director for a five-year term.  I think that's wrong for several reasons. First, the obvious: the process of nomination and confirmation is not […]

Report That English Seeking to Enjoin Mulvaney from Serving as Acting CFPB Director

by Jeff Sovern Kate Berry has the story in the American Banker.  She reports that the case will be filed in federal court in Washington, D.C., possibly as early as this evening. The report states that one of English's anticipated theories is that Trump is attempting to assert control of an independent agency by naming […]

How the OLC Has Gone Astray on the CFPB

by Jeff Sovern The Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel has now issued an opinion which, not surprisingly, expresses the view that the president can name the acting director of the CFPB. It argues that even though the VRA specifies that it is the "exclusive" way to fill vacancies "unless another statute 'expressly'  provides […]