Mulvaney in Bureau’s Semi-Annual Report Calls for Limiting CFPB Independence

by Jeff Sovern

The report is here. Here's an excerpt from Mulvaney's statement at the beginning of the report:

As has been evident since the enactment of the Dodd-Frank Act, the Bureau is far too powerful, and with precious little oversight of its activities. Per the statute, in the normal course the Bureau’s Director simultaneously serves in three roles: as a one-man legislature empowered to write rules to bind parties in new ways; as an executive officer subject to limited control by the President; and as an appellate judge presiding over the Bureau’s in-house court-like adjudications. In Federalist No. 47, James Madison famously wrote that “[t]he accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands … may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.” Constitutional separation of powers and related checks and balances protect us from government overreach. And while Congress may not have transgressed any constraints established by the Supreme Court, the structure and powers of this agency are not something the Founders and Framers would recognize. By structuring the Bureau the way it has, Congress established an agency primed to ignore due process and abandon the rule of law in favor of bureaucratic fiat and administrative absolutism. 

The best that any Bureau Director can do on his own is to fulfill his responsibilities with humility and prudence, and to temper his decisions with the knowledge that the power he wields could all too easily be used to harm consumers, destroy businesses, or arbitrarily remake American financial markets. But all human beings are imperfect, and history shows that the temptation of power is strong. Our laws should be written to restrain that human weakness, not empower it.

I have no doubt that many Members of Congress disagree with my actions as the Acting Director of the Bureau, just as many Members disagreed with the actions of my predecessor. Such continued frustration with the Bureau’s lack of accountability to any representative branch of government should be a warning sign that a lapse in democratic structure and republican
principles has occurred. This cycle will repeat ad infinitum unless Congress acts to make it accountable to the American people.

Accordingly, I request that Congress make four changes to the law to establish meaningful accountability for the Bureau:

1. Fund the Bureau through Congressional appropriations;
2. Require legislative approval of major Bureau rules;
3. Ensure that the Director answers to the President in the exercise of executive authority; and4. Create an independent Inspector General for the Bureau.                 

0 thoughts on “Mulvaney in Bureau’s Semi-Annual Report Calls for Limiting CFPB Independence

  1. Veronica Schweyen says:

    Mr. Mulvaney is now advocating for the removal of the CFPB’s powers to over-see the actions of Unjust and Unlawful actions by big Corporations. I hope that his wishes to stop the powers of the CFPB will be over-rules by Congress. Doesn’t he know that the big Banks had stolen Billions of dollars from tax payers during the Recession? He has to STOP FAVORING THE BIG BANKS!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *