Dan Solove gives the pending privacy bill a B+ but pans preemption

Here.  Excerpt:

One possible compromise: The ADPPA could contain a preemption provision that would sunset after 5 or 10 years unless Congress would amend the law to renew the preemption term for another 5-10 years. This would force Congress to revisit the law in order to renew the preemption for another period.