Third Circuit holds that a lawyer’s Amazon rder does not create personal jurisdiction

When Promier Products, an Illinois-based flashlight seller suspected other Amazon sellers were falsely advertising the brightness of their products, its lawyers ordered the competitors’ products to their Pittsburgh office.  Promier’s lawyers tested the flashlights, and found they were indeed not as bright as promised, and then brought a false advertising suit in the Western District of Pennsylvania against the 153 Chinese competitors.

The district court denied a preliminary injunction, holding, among other things, that the Promier could not use its lawyers’ test buys to manufacture jurisdiction in Pennsylvania. In a decision issued yesterday on appeal in Promier Products Inc. v. Gearoz, the Third Circuit agreed. It held that the orders for testing purposes  could not create specific jurisdiction for the false advertising claims, as those claims “arise out of defendants’ sales to deceived customers,” not of their sales to the law firm. Nonetheless, the Third Circuit recognized that jurisdictional discovery might show that personal jurisdiction existed, and also that some of the defendants may have waived any personal jurisdiction challenge–and thus vacated and remanded for further proceedings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *