Category Archives: Uncategorized

Court affirms class certification in case about Facebook’s facial-recognition technology

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday affirmed the district court’s order certifying a class Facebook users in a case challenging Facebook’s facial-recognition technology as a violation of Illinois’s Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA).The court held that plaintiffs alleged a concrete and particularized harm, sufficient to confer Article III standing, because BIPA protected the […]

Empirical analysis of the Supreme Court’s class-action cases

Scotusblog this week posted an analysis of the U.S. Supreme Court's review of class action cases. Among its observations is that the Court overturns almost 70 percent of class action decisions made by appeals courts by either reversing or vacating these decisions. In addition, the analysis found that, between the 2010 and 2018 terms, the […]

FTC update on claims in Equifax settlement

Last week, the Federal Trade Commission announced a $700 million settlement with Equifax concerning its liability for the 2017 data breach in which hackers stole the personal information of 147 million people. The settlement seemed to offer people as much as $125 in cash. In the week after the FTC announced the settlement, more than […]

Subpoenas to Identify Online Consumer Critics on the Ground That They Weren’t Really Customers

by Paul Alan Levy What sort of showing must a criticized business make when it wants to identify an anonymous online critic on the theory that the critic was never an actual customer and that, consequently, any criticisms are necessarily false? Attorney Thomas P. Kelly III of Santa Rosa California That issue has been presented […]

California Supreme Court rejects strict class-certification “ascertainability” requirement

The California Supreme Court today issued its unanimous decision in Noel v. Thrifty Payless Inc., which rejected a strict class-certification "ascertainability" requirement sometimes associated with decisions of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. This paragraph sums up the issue and the court's conclusion: This case is a putative class action brought on […]

The conservative case for class actions

Professor Brian Fitzpatrick has a new book, set for release in October, called The Conservative case for Class Actions. Here is the summary: Since the 1960s, the class action lawsuit has been a powerful tool for holding businesses accountable. Yet years of attacks by corporate America and unfavorable rulings by the Supreme Court have left […]

The conflict between the increasingly restrictive due-process constraints on personal jurisdiction and substantive state products-liability law

That's the topic of The New Privity by law prof Alexi Lahav. I thought the article would be interesting to our readers, who (1) may be concerned about the Supreme Court's expanding due-process restrictions on where alleged corporate wrongdoers may be sued and (2) want products-liability law to remain robust and adaptable. Here is the […]

Eleventh Circuit rejects class-action attorney’s fee multiplier

In In re the Home Depot Customer Data Security Breach Litig.,the Eleventh Circuit has held that when a defendant agrees to pay class-action fees in a class-action settlement, in an amount to be determined by the district judge, separate from the fund set up by the settlement to compensate class members, the attorney's fee may […]

FTC imposes $5 billion penalty and new privacy restrictions on Facebook

The Federal Trade Commission announced this morning that it has reached a settlement with Facebook over the FTC's charges that the company violated a 2012 FTC order by deceiving users about their ability to control the privacy of their personal information. Under the settlement, Facebook will pay a $5 billion penalty and submit to new […]