Category Archives: Uncategorized

Applebee’s workers to Second Circuit: the Supreme Court’s Comcast decision doesn’t undermine wage-and-hour class actions

Today Public Citizen filed the opening brief in an appeal on behalf of a putative class of Applebee's workers throughout New York State. The workers sued their employer, T.L. Cannon, owner and operator of 53 Applebee's locations in New York, claiming various wage violations, including that the employer trained its supervisors and managers to manipulate […]

Op-ed on Chief Justice’s statement regarding cy pres and other invitations from the Court

Linda Greenhouse had this interesting piece in the New York Times yesterday, about Chief Justice Roberts's "invitation" to cases challenging cy pres awards, as she describes the Chief Justice's statement (at p. 24 of the pdf) last week concerning the denial of the petiton for certiorari in Marek v. Lane–the cert petition about the cy […]

Google Books Program Upheld as Fair Use

by Paul Alan Levy The major ruling of the day:  Circuit Judge Denny Chin, sitting as a trial judge because he retained the case after being promoted to the Second Circuit, has granted summary judgment  rejecting the Authors Guild’s copyright claims against Google’s program of scanning books into digital form and both offering the digital […]

More on settlement of Mt. Holly case

Jeff posted earlier about settlement of the Mt. Holly case shortly before argument in the Supreme Court. The case presented the question whether disparate impact claims may be brought under the Fair Housing Act, which prohibits housing discrimination (or, on the other hand, whether plaintiffs must show intentional discrimination to prevail under the Act). There […]

Are state parens patriae suits “mass actions” under the Class Action Fairness Act?

Last week, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Mississippi ex rel. Hood v. AU Optronics Corp., which presents the question whether a state’s parens patriae suit may be removed as a “mass action” under the Class Action Fairness Act when the state is the sole plaintiff, the claims arise under state law, and the state […]

The effects of the Supreme Court’s rules on summary judgment and pleading requirements on case outcomes

Lawyers for consumers and other plaintiffs have long complained that the Supreme Court's cases making summary judgment and dismissal easier to obtain have had adverse effects on their clients. That's not surprising. (For instance, it is the plaintiff who will be on the losing end of a successful motion to dismiss.) Now, law professors Kevin […]

“Common Problems for the Common Answers Test: Class Certification in Amgen and Comcast”

That is the name of this article by law professor Mark Moller. Here is the abstract: The Supreme Court’s 2011 decision, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes, drew heavily on the work of the late Professor Richard Nagareda. In a series of seminal articles, Professor Nagareda urged courts to treat class action procedure as a handmaiden […]

NYT: Federal CARD act successful in saving consumers from hidden credit card fees

As this article from late last week explains, a new study of the effects of the 2009 Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure (CARD) Act finds that the Act is saving consumers more than $20 billion dollars a year by placing limits on certain credit card company practices that could lead to surprise fees for […]

The CFPB’s favorite enforcement targets: banks (no surprise there) and lawyers

According to this article by Jenna Greene, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has been targetting lawyers in its enforcement suits. Here's an excerpt: The agency has filed more lawsuits against lawyers than almost any other group, according to an analysis by The National Law Journal, bringing six suits against legal services providers. Only the banking […]