Author Archives: Jeff Sovern

GOP legislators accuse CFPB of colluding with states, as Kraninger did

by Jeff Sovern Three House Republicans have accused CFPB director Rohit Chopra of “colluding with states” and “conspiring with state agencies.” And yet, the Trump-nominated CFPB director Kathy Kraninger collaborated with state attorneys general, as for example, in the Bureau’s settlement with Nationstar Mortgage. I wonder if the legislators complained about Kraninger colluding with states.

WSJ: Equifax Sent Lenders Inaccurate Credit Scores on Millions of Consumers

Here but paywalled. Excerpt: * * * The scores were sometimes off by 20 points or more in either direction, the people said, enough to alter the interest rates consumers were offered or to result in their applications being rejected altogether. * * * “We have determined that there was no shift in the vast […]

Unfairness and Disparate Effects

by Jeff Sovern As we wrote about in May, the CFPB takes the position that it can use its unfairness power when consumer financial service companies discriminate. One issue that has arisen is whether when it does so, the Bureau will use the disparate effects test, sometimes called the disparate impact test, to determine if […]

OCC CFP: THE IMPLICATIONS OF FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY FOR BANKING

From the CFP: The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) is soliciting academic-and policy-focused research on the impact of financial technology (fintech) entities and nonbanks on banking and the markets for lending, deposit-taking, and payment services through August 21, 2022. The OCC will invite authors of selected papers to present to OCC staff […]

Dan Solove gives the pending privacy bill a B+ but pans preemption

Here.  Excerpt: One possible compromise: The ADPPA could contain a preemption provision that would sunset after 5 or 10 years unless Congress would amend the law to renew the preemption term for another 5-10 years. This would force Congress to revisit the law in order to renew the preemption for another period.

Paper responds to Wilf-Townsend’s Assembly-Line Plaintiffs

Last year, we published a link to Daniel Wilf-Townsend's Harvard Law Review article  Assembly-Line Plaintiffs. Now Jessica Steinberg of George Washington, Colleen F. Shanahan of Columbia, Anna E. Carpenter of Utah, and Alyx Mark of Wesleyan's Dept. of Government and the American Bar Foundation have written a response to it, The Democratic (Il)legitimacy of Assembly-Line […]

WSJ: CFPB working on guidance to force banks to cover more scams on Zelle and similar apps

by Jeff Sovern Here, behind a pay wall. Excerpt: At present, banks generally are only required to repay consumers for payments they didn’t authorize. The coming regulatory guidance could change that threshold by maintaining that fraudulently induced transactions, even those approved by the consumer, are considered unauthorized. That could require a bank to conduct more […]

Will Congress pass an online privacy bill?

by Jeff Sovern The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Commerce has forwarded to the full committee a bipartisan bill (draft here, though perhaps not the version the subcommittee approved; section-by-section commentary here). The last I heard, Senator Cantwell, the Senate Commerce Committee chair, had not signed on, putting the bill's future […]

Chao paper suggests unjust enrichment claims confer standing, even after TransUnion

Bernard Chao of Denver has written Unjust Enrichment: Standing Up for Privacy Rights. Here is the abstract: In TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, one of the country’s largest credit reporting agencies violated the Federal Credit Report Act (“FCRA”) by failing to “follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy . . ..” As a result, thousands of […]