Eleventh Circuit upholds CFPB rules applying TILA and RESPA to “PACE” financing schemes

In February, I posted about a district court decision rejecting an industry challenge to CFPB rules applying TILA and RESPA to Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing systems. Under these programs, a homeowner borrows money to finance certain residential energy and home improvement projects, and the loan is repaid through an assessment on the homeowner’s property tax bill. The lender’s lien generally has priority over mortgage liens, and the assessment runs with the property.

In 2018, in response to some concerns about the practice–including reports of homeowners who had not even realized they were taking out a loan, Congress passed legislation mandating the CFPB promulgate a rule applying the purposes of the “ability-to-repay” and related civil liability provisions of TILA to PACE financing. In January 2025, the CFPB promulgated that rule, and went further– applying nearly all TILA provisions and some provisions of RESPA to PACE financing transactions. A trade association, “Building Resilient Infrastructure and Developing Greater Equity, Inc.,” was created in Florida and sued there, challenging the rule as in excess of the CFPB’s statutory authority, arbitrary and capricious, violative of the Regulatory Flexibility Act and Tenth Amendment.

The district court held that that PACE financing is “credit” under TILA, and thus that the CFPB had authority to regulate it under that statute–irrespective of the 2018 rule. It also held that PACE financing is not a tax, even though loans are recouped via tax assessments, but rather creates a debt.

Last week, a unanimous panel of the Eleventh Circuit agreed with the district court, and held that the rule was a proper exercise of the CFPB’s statutory rulemaking authority, was not arbitrary or capricious, and did not violate the Tenth Amendment.  The court held that PACE loans are “consumer credit transactions” under TILA, despite the plaintiff’s attempt to recharacterize them as “tax assessments. Relatedly, it rejected the plaintiff’s attempt to paint the loans as an exercise of sovereign tax authority for 10th Amendment purposes, explaining that the fact “[t]hat the governments use tax bills as the vehicle for collecting debt payment
does not transform the loans into taxes.”  The court also held that the fact that Congress only *required* the CFPB to apply some provisions of TILA to PACE financing did not mean the agency was precluded from relying on its preexisting authority to further regulate PACE financing transactions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *