Author Archives: Paul Levy

Google Books Program Upheld as Fair Use

by Paul Alan Levy The major ruling of the day:  Circuit Judge Denny Chin, sitting as a trial judge because he retained the case after being promoted to the Second Circuit, has granted summary judgment  rejecting the Authors Guild’s copyright claims against Google’s program of scanning books into digital form and both offering the digital […]

Is it worse to be called “the Government” than “the State of Tennessee?

by Paul Alan Levy In this motion a prosecutor asked a trial judge to order a particular defense lawyer to stop referring to her during jury trials as “the Government” on the ground that jurors would likely take this as a derogatory reference “and is meant to make the State’s attorneys seem oppressive and to […]

NSA Compounds Its Assaults on Privacy by Attacking Critical Speech

by Paul Alan Levy Over the years I have blogged several times about corporate abuses of trademark law to use litigation, or the threat of litigation to block criticism.  Because they have so many other tools to deploy against citizens, government agencies usually do not stoop to this level – the City of Memphis aside […]

“Federal Verification Company” Seeks to Shut Down Online Criticism

by Paul Alan Levy A Tampa-area company called “Federal Verification Co.,” which operates under “dozens of names,” according to the author of this exposé on a local television station, has filed a defamation lawsuit against its online critics, and is using vague allegations about defamation on a number of sites as an excuse for a […]

Thomas Cooley Law School Loses Libel Suit — Among Other Reasons, Charges Against It Are True

by Paul Alan Levy One of the worst things that can happen to libel plaintiffs is to lose the suit in a way that confirms the veracity of the charges made publicly against it.  This is what recently happened to Thomas Cooley law School.  Past articles here have discussed its efforts to identify a former […]

APWU Attacks on Its Members’ Democratic Rights — One Down, One to Go

by Paul Alan Levy Over the course of more than twenty years of representing union members in litigation over issues of union democracy, before my main focus switched to Internet law and IP issues, I found that in some unions, the leaders think nothing of spending other peoples’ money – the union treasury that is […]

Are Manhattan Lasik Center’s discount coupons worth buying?

by Paul Alan Levy The Manhattan Lasik Center secures customers, in part, by offering discounts through Groupon and similar online marketing programs.  For a $1795 Groupon, for example, a customer can get lasik treatment for both eyes.  Several reviews posted on Yelp, however, suggest that it is not at all unusual for patients to appear […]

Frivolous Libel Threats – the Reality Show

by Paul Alan Levy Last October, blogger Christina Garner posted an introspective article reflecting on media coverage of a lawsuit in which Tonya Cooley, a reality-show participant, alleged that two fellow participants had assaulted her sexually in a sequence that did not appear in the broadcast, including inserting a toothbrush into her while she was […]