Author Archives: Paul Levy

Use of Search Warrants to Create Trump Enemies List Continues

by Paul Alan Levy In a motion to quash filed today, three Facebook users are challenging search warrants issued by federal prosecutors seeking to rummage through accounts in which they supported protests against the inauguration of Donald Trump on the weekend of January 20. One of the accounts may be the Facebook analogue of the […]

Response to Trump Prosecutors’ Effort to Attack Peaceful Protests

by Paul Alan Levy In my blog post yesterday about developments in the litigation over the search warrant to DreamHost, I recounted the encouraging signs from DC Superior Court Chief Judge Morin’s written order and colloquys with counsel during oral argument  at a hearing this week about his determination to protect the privacy rights of […]

DC Court Narrows Prosecutors Options for Searching Trump Inauguration Protest Web Site

by Paul Alan Levy Late last week, DC Superior Court Chief Judge Robert Morin issued an opinion  explaining his oral ruling at last month’s hearing on a search warrant issued to DreamHost demanding production of its files pertaining to DisruptJ20.org, and rejecting the rival proposed orders filed by the prosecutors and by DreamHost. We were […]

Anonymous Users’ Objection to Search Warrant Seeking to Identify Users Who Communicated with Trump Inauguration Protest Site

by Paul Alan Levy Today we filed our brief on behalf of three anonymous Internet users who object to the breadth of the proposed orders submitted by the Government and by DreamHost, each spelling out their alternative versions of the how Chief Judge Robert Morin had articulated his ruling that enforced a narrowed search warrant […]

Anonymous Users Who Emailed the DisruptJ20 Web Site, and Who Received Emails From That Site, Seek Court Protection for Their Anonymity

by Paul Alan Levy In a motion for leave to intervene filed today, three anonymous Internet users who sought information from the DisruptJ20 web site, who joined listservs through which such information was communicated, or who volunteered to provide legal support work for the range of nonviolent protest activities advertised on the site, are asking […]

Court Grants Motion to Compel DreamHost to Obey Warrant, but Restricts Search Process and Use of Data

by Paul Alan Levy In a decision issued late Thursday morning, DC Superior Court Chief Judge Robert Morin said that he was ready to order DreamHost to comply with the federal prosecutors’ scaled-down search warrant, but enunciated strict procedural restrictions that he said were intended to reflect a balance between allowing the Government to pursue […]

Trump Administration Backs Off on Identifying Anonymous Web Site Viewers, But Important Free Speech Issues for Some Web Viewers Remain

by Paul Alan Levy Responding to an outpouring of popular outrage as well as legal filings (including one from Public Citizen as well as an amicus brief from Avaaz) showing that the First Amendment protects the right to read anonymously and can be used to limit the enforcement of criminal discovery demands seeking to identify […]

Can law bloggers be subjected to Bar discipline for misstating facts or law?

by Paul Alan Levy On Friday morning, a panel at the annual meeting in New York of the Association of Professional Responsibility Lawyers will be discussing an issue dear to the heart of blawgers who discuss subjects that make powerful figures in their own areas uncomfortable – to what extent should lawyers be subject to […]

Internet Providers Have Standing to Protect Their Users’ Anonymity

by Paul Alan Levy This past spring, Twitter garnered significant attention, and widespread praise, for a lawsuit it brought against the Trump Administration this past spring to block enforcement of an administrative summons seeking to identify the owners of a Twitter account purporting to reflect criticisms by current employees in Customs and Border Control. The […]